What Are Scope 3 Emissions And Why Should Trucking Companies Care? – Fuel Smarts

In conversations with customers about sustainability, trucking companies are likely going to hear the terms Scope 1, Scope 2, and Scope 3 greenhouse gas emissions.

• Scope 1 emissions are direct emissions that result from the assets that you own. If you own trucks, you are producing a lot of Scope 1 emissions. “For trucking companies, that’s been predominantly where we have been spending a lot of our time and attention is on our Scope 1 reductions and plans to reduce those emissions,” says Shawntell Kroese, AVP of sustainability and sales operations for Werner Enterprises.
• Scope 2 emissions result from the electricity that you buy and pull from the grid to power your facilities. How much do you use? What’s the source of the energy?
• Scope 3 is everything else, and a huge part of that is a company’s supply chain. “It’s indirect emissions, both upstream and downstream, in the whole supply chain process,” Kroese says. “And so it’s complicated. There are a lot of different categories, as you think through your business, and what you would include in terms of the activities of your company.”

How Trucking Companies Can Help Customers Be Greener

The key for trucking in this discussion is that a fleet’s Scope 1 emissions are part of a shipper’s Scope 3 emissions. And large companies, for many reasons, are looking to reduce those emissions.

“That’s why we’re a big deal to our customers, because we’re a big part of their Scope 3,” says Kroese.

Werner’s goal is to disclose Scope 1 and Scope 2 GHG emissions in 2025. Scope 1 is being disclosed now, and the trucking giant said it’s on track to report Scope 2 by 2025.

So far, Werner said in its latest sustainability report, it has achieved a 16% Scope 1 emissions reduction. To calculate Scope 2 data, the company has been building a waste and energy scorecard to measure progress around waste reduction and electricity use.

For private fleets, determining their Scope 1, Scope 2, and Scope 3 emissions often are part of a larger corporate focus on ESG and sustainability goals.

Sysco, for instance, set an ambitious science-based climate goal to reduce its global Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions by 27.5% by 2030 compared to a 2019 baseline. And it has committed to working with suppliers representing 67% of Scope 3 emissions to set their own targets by 2026​. 

In its latest Corporate Social Responsibility report, Sysco said it is transitioning to a new, global emissions tracking platform so it will be able to report those Scope 1 and 2 emissions.

Regulations’ Role in Scope 3 Emissions Focus

You may have heard about Scope 3 emissions in the news during the past year or two.

California last fall passed a law requiring emissions reporting from large companies, including Scope 3 emissions. The California Climate Accountability Act applies to both

public and private companies that do business in the state and make more than $1 billion in annual revenue.

What exactly those regulations will include, and what legal challenges may mean to the eventual rules, is yet to be seen.

In January, a coalition of business organizations filed a legal challenge, saying the new laws will impose “massive” costs on businesses, violate free speech protections, and act as de facto national emissions regulations, usurping the role of federal regulators as set up under the Clean Air Act.

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission recently published new rules requiring greenhouse gas emissions reporting from publicly traded companies. Those rules did not go as far as requiring Scope 3 emissions reporting, as the SEC had originally proposed.

“The Scope 3 is just a bear,” explains Beth Davis-Sramek, the chair of the Department of Supply Chain Management at Auburn University in Alabama. “It’s the big companies, the big globals, that are trying to figure out how to tackle that.

“For most companies, if you’re getting a sense of what your Scope 1 and Scope 2 are, you’re way ahead of the curve.”

Why Do My Customers Want to Know My Trucking Company’s Scope 3 Emissions?

Davis-Sramek explains the recent focus on Scope 3 emissions this way:

“Companies such as Apple have been really good at saying, ‘We’re carbon neutral.’ But Apple doesn’t own anything. Everything is manufactured abroad. They don’t have trucks, they don’t have manufacturing; they outsource it. So their Scope 1 and Scope 2 numbers are tiny.

“If you look at Scope 3, if you look at their supply chain, and you think about where’s the social and the environmental concerns, it’s in their supply chain.

“So now companies, the big ones, are on the hook to manage their supply chains and to think about, ’How am I dealing with my Scope 3 emissions?”

Since a motor carrier’s Scope 1 emissions are part of shippers’ Scope 3 emissions, she says, “Now they’re on the hook to demonstrate that they’re doing something about your emissions.

“This is where I think companies are going to be pressured,” she says. “It’s going to be the small and medium sized companies that are a part of bigger supply chains that are going to be under pressure for this kind of reporting system.”